Validating CDA Documents

I received sample CCD files from a trading partner. I ran their sample files against the NIST validator and the first file had over 50 errors against the base CDA schema. They had used the data type PQ for all results in the results section. Some of those results were not physical quantities. Like so:

<value unit="ML/MIN/1.73M2" value=">60" xsi:type="PQ"/>

<value unit="MIU/ML" value="<2" xsi:type="PQ"/>

<value unit="UNK" value="///" xsi:type="PQ"/>

<value unit="UNK" value="NOT DETECTED" xsi:type="PQ"/>

<value unit="UNK" value="Negative" xsi:type="PQ"/>

<value unit="UNK" value="neg" xsi:type="PQ"/>

There is a LOINC code for Serum Cholesterol. All of the codes were either "0" or "UNK".

I went in and manually fixed the data type errors.

This is invalid:

<value unit="UNK" value="neg" xsi:type="PQ"/>

"neg" is not a physical quantity. Send this as a code, instead.

This is correct:


<value xsi:type="CD" code="260385009" displayName="Negative" codeSystem="2.16.840.1.113883.6.96" codeSystemName="SNOMED-CT"/>

This is invalid:

<value unit="UNK" value="pos" xsi:type="PQ"/>

"pos" is not a physical quantity. Send this as a code, instead.

This is correct:

<value xsi:type="CD" code="10828004" displayName="Positive" codeSystem="2.16.840.1.113883.6.96" codeSystemName="SNOMED-CT"/>

This is invalid:

<value unit="UNK" value="NOT DETECTED" xsi:type="PQ"/>

"not detected" is not a physical quantity. Send this as a code, instead.

<value code="260415000" codeSystemName="SNOMED-CT" displayName="Not Detected" codeSystem ="2.16.840.1.113883.6.96" xsi:type="CD"/>

This is invalid:

<value unit="MIU/ML" value="<2" xsi:type="PQ"/>

"<2" is not a physical quantity. Use interval of physical quantity as the data type, instead.

This is correct:

<value xsi:type="IVL_PQ">
<high unit="MIU/ML" value="2"></high>
</value>

This is invalid:

<value unit="ML/MIN/1.73M2" value=">60" xsi:type="PQ"/>

">60" is not a physical quantity. Use interval of physical quantity as the data type, instead.

This is correct:

<value xsi:type="IVL_PQ">
<low unit="ML/MIN/1.73M2" value="60"></low>
</value>

There are many undefined codes in the document. These need to be provided.

<code code="0" codeSystem="2.16.840.1.113883.6.12" codeSystemName="CPT-4" displayName="UNK">

<code code="UNK" codeSystem="2.16.840.1.113883.5.83" displayName="HDL CHOLESTEROL"/>

I asked the HL7 Structured Documents mailing list how they would deal with this document. Some vendors got defensive. It was an interesting exchange.